Money does not grow on trees

September 23, 2012 at 12:01 pm 6 comments

‘Money does not grow on trees” I heard my mother say this way back in the early 40s.It was then just during and after the Second World War and there was acute scarcity of rice and other commodities. Life was difficult for us kids when we did not know the value of money and made demands. Then my mother told us once ‘Money does not grow on trees’ She was not a Harvard educated woman neither was she in power. She was trying to put some sense in us by sayings with which we were familiar -because we had coconut trees-mangoes and guavas trees. She was just an 8th standard educated homemaker. So we understood what these trees yielded and their limitations. That was a good reminder to us children who knew to climb the trees and pluck the fruits but surely there was no money yielding trees!
Now after about 70 years I am hearing the same words from the Prime Minister of India –a Harvard educated economist who addressed the aam admis and reminded them that -‘Money does not grow on trees’. Should we not be immensely grateful to him for sharing this piece of wisdom which he suddenly was enlightened with. He also shared with us some that sent down the shivers-that we are in the same crisis as in 1997.He appealed to us to strengthen his hands.
Mr Prime Minister-do you think that aam admis do not know that ‘money does not grow on trees’? Is a shared piece of enlightenment to which you suddenly woke up to or is it a rebuke?
Granted Prime Minister we are kids-we are ignorant and do not understand the nuances of economies as your economic advisor Mr Rajagarajan and the Planning Commissioner Montek Ahluwalla (the latter said that the diesel price hike is good move but not a reform)do so let us thank the PM for this sharing. But then you in the same breathe talked of a crisis similar to the one experience in India in the 90s and then no one wanted to loan us even money. How did you wake up to this piece of knowledge suddenly? When did this crisis loom large and what were you doing all these 8 years. By your very admission of the crisis have you not admitted that you are responsible for the crisis? Please tell your Congress men/women not to point at the NDA and for everything parrot like repeat that the UPA followed the same policy as the NDA be in the 2G-Spectrum or in the natural resources of this country. But then don’t you have your own policy? Why had you to follow the NDA policy? Is that not accepting the fact that you as an economist did not have an economic policy of your own? Why this suddenly awakening from your hibernation Have the remote control been switched off now? Why had you not appealed to the nation to strength your hands if you had requested your scam indulging ministers to put in their papers? Were you such a spineless Prime minister that you simply looked the other way when they were looting the country and now you plead to the people to strengthen your hands? Strengthen your hands for what Mr PM-to sell this country to the foreigners? Was it not enough and satisfying to you that you are remotely controlled by Mrs Sonia Gandhi of foreign origin? Tell me which county and which people would accept this situation when as a PM you are unable to proceed with reforms, when you are unable to stem the crisis and when you give us the impression that you seem to shiver of fear and allow the Sonia Gandhi headed NAC to dictate terms-chalk out bills and pass it on to you.
Did you not know that the resources of this country belong to its people? Now why are you coming just when you hardly have two years to go to tell the people that unless we bring in firm reforms we are doomed? Which world were you in? Mr Prime Minister did you realize that your so called reforms are all acclaimed by the Corporate world. While the aam admis are groaning and moaning under the price rise. Why is it that your government is trying to import coal from Canada and sell it for a lower price to private persons? Are you their broker? Why do you want to cause this loss to the aam admis money? Why not at least sell it at the same price? What kind of economics is this to buy at one price and sell it at a lower price? Where does the profit go from the private entrepreneurs (politicians and corporates).Is that another scam in the making?
You say that subsidy must go –and you compare us with Pakistan and want us to thank our stars that there the petrol and diesel is more costlier than in India..Mr Prime Minister what were the austerity measures you unfolded to curb the heavy spending of the GOI. Was there a white paper placed in Parliament? By the way thank you for reminding us that money does not grow on trees. But it looks that money grow in scams-in the 2-G spectrum- Money grows in the bowels of the earth when Mr Chidambaram says–the coals are there safe within the mother earth.hence we have the coalgate scams growing money Then why this cancellation of the coal blocks? So with the mother earth below –and up in the air waves money grows and multiples for your ministers(some of then) and the netas to loot. What did the economist in you then do –why were you so unfazed?Yes I forgot to mention that the money which do not grow on trees grew in the Swiss banks? From where and how did the money come to be stashed away in tax havens? The President who had the names of the looters and the black money people did not want to share their names quoting all sorts of treaties. We are simple people and do not understand the functioning of this secrecy. All that we know is that people’s money has been swindled and hoarded and it is as simple as this-people have a right to know who these swindlers are. Now Mr Pranab Mukherjee is safely cocooned in the Rashtrapathi Bhavan.Why have all conspired against the aam admis?
We are told that the Opposition did not allow the Parliament to function.Parliament was blocked and we had the media-both print and electronic faulting the Opposition for this.To some extent one would agree that Parliament is the best forum for the expression of democracy.But our Parliament has been turned into a debating Club.The full throated gets the marks and they are satisfied that their duty has been done. What was the result of all the debates in Parliament these years that you were in power?It was only on blocking Parliament that A.Raja put in his papers.What had happened to all the scams including that of the Common Wealth Games?Has a single person been charge sheeted.Why debates I would like to ask the UPA.And we had Mrs Sonia Gandhi taking umbrage at Advani saying that this government is illegitimate.Her catholic instincts were scandalized.What is the legitimacy of this government.A juggerly of numbers.If one M walks out there is another M to lend support and it the seond M has his own private agenda then there is a third M waiting by the sides.So this is the legitimacy of the UPA 2 and we call this democacry.No,there is a new perceptionh-that of a co-alit ion dharma.What is the opposite of legitimacy? Hence why did Mrs Sonia Gandhi get so perturbed bv that ‘illegitimacy’ word that she prodded her party men and women to shout back and condemn. This is Parliament functioning. To ask questions money is given-Money bags are exhibited on the floor of the Parliament and we call this democracy? If for one vote Buta Singh could exchange suitcase of money-that becomes legitimate. We do not want this kind of governance and term it democracy. Mr Prime Minister when had democracy two power centers? What is the exact role of Mrs Sonia Gandhi in governance? How are why are you obliged to heed her advice? Is it because she handpicked you for the Prime Minister’s post? What does she understand of the economics of this country and for that matter the aspirations of the people of this country.
I would totally agree with Mamata-she may be a firebrand but she had some common sense-more than some. She terms your government as rule of the foreigners by the foreigners and for the foreigners. Watching your so called reforms one would agree in totality with her. Are we to watch the total surrender of this country to foreigners in the name of reforms? Remember the East India Company they came as mere traders and then ruled this country and became an Imperial power. But then when on a visit to the UK you praised Britain for what it did to India. That is your mindset. Even when you were heading the World Bank did you Mr Manmohan Singh stand up for the under developed countries. The same when you were in SAARC? You have a kind of a mind set that is subservient to the Imperialistic powers and to anything and everything foreign. A scan of your workings will reveal this. You showed a kind of a stubbornness when it came to signing the N-deal and you were prepared even to resign Why had you not shown the same grit and courage when it came to dealing with the scams and the scam esters? What goes beyond my ordinary comprehension is the fact of your inactive posture all these years and you have suddenly come out of your hibernation-It did hurt when you were termed as the ‘underachiever’ by Time and later when a damaging progress report of your governance as PM was made by the Washington Post. May be these two rattled you. Because you are very sensitive what the foreigners say of you-of what they get out of this country and what they think and feel of your governance.
We want democracy but we must decide on what kind of democracy the Congress can offer when it has no democracy of its own. It is a fact that you cannot give what you do not have when dynastic regimes are established. What has come to stay when even a reluctant Rahul Gandhi is being pushed as No 2 in the Congress party it is very apparent that brains and hard work do not count. This is a sad commentary on the state of political environment that has been created in this country. Do you call this democracy? And then to lament that the Opposition blocked Parliament and the media steps in to calculate the amount of loss in crores when Parliament did not work. But then what about the loss in lakhs of crores of rupees when Parliament did work but achieved nothing except shouting at each other. Please do not turn Parliament into a debating society and think that running the Parliament thus is a mark of democracy. Running the Parliament is your duty and it is the duty of the government to have taken the Opposition in confidence on all major issues. Would the heavens had fallen if all the coalgate blocks were cancelled and that condition which the Opposition held out for allowing Parliament to function was met? You and your party were not keen on running the Parliament so why blame the Opposition.
Finally Mr Prime Minister please see that Hasan Ali Khan,Telgi and others pay their taxes or declare them as criminals and put them behind the bars. It is a travesty of truth when you want only to burden the common people and allow these tax evaders to go scot free. If you really mean business then bring back the Black money hoarded in tax havens and do not take us for a ride. Your FM cites that more reforms are to come –if you are not able to hold the price line and bring down the prices of the ordinary food items, vegetables, cooking oil and those things which people (half the population)who require only 6 cylinders a year need, then what is the use of these reforms?
The people will not sit back and watch you making this democratic Republic a banana republic and convert the GOI into a Corporate. That is not democracy. We are simple people and understand only simple logic. We will not allow looters to be in the government and we will not tolerate the netas to lord over us. We will not allow the food grains to be fed to rodents and fatten then while half the population go hunger. We will not allow the dual power centre and we want democracy to uphold the Constitution and not tamper with it. We will not allow the nation to be segmented into ghettos on the basis of religion and we will not sit back and watch ministers like SM.Krishnan waste precious time and money on talking of group tours in Pakistan without making any substantial progress on terrorism with his Pakistani counterpart. It is like fooling around and running round the bush without facing serious concerns. This is just one example of the way ministers work.
If Parliament does not work how much of work do your ministries turn out and what does it costs the aam admis to run this GOI? Accountability for the hard earned money is a prerequisite in good governance and we find it nil. What streamlining have you done in governance? What austerity measures had you taken during your tenure? Please do not point at the NDA and tell us that you follow its policy. That’s a shame and at least the NDA did not have two power centres and had no dynastic rule. This is a contradiction to democracy and hence not allowing the Parliament to function alone is no negation of democracy. The functioning of Parliament must produce fruitful discussions-debates and bring in logical legislation not while away the time. We ordinary people are fully aware of the way the political class like leeches are sucking the blood of the nation and weakening the polity. This will not endure for long.
I hope in the name of reforms you are not adding to the burden of the already burdened aam admis and then go waving the HAND asking for their votes-you will get none. What a pity Prime Minister that like Peter the Piper you are piping the reform tune but we shall not follow you for we are not children to follow Peter the Piper to their doom
You had lost a chance Mr Prime Minister to go down in history as a reformist when you failed to usher in reforms in 2009.Today as Mr Swapan Dasgupta says in his ‘Rousing a sleeping giant without moral authority’(TOI 23rd Sept)”If PM Singh was indeed the great reformer he is portrayed to be he would have unleashed Indian’s “Animal instincts” immediately after his May 2009 victory when he had little to fear but fear itself. Instead ,he waited till the GDP growth had fallen below 6%,the rupee is fragile, inflation soaring, the fiscal deficit out of control, politics vitiated by corruption scandals and business confidence at an all time low”.It is in this context that it looks ridiculous for the PM to ask the people to strengthen his hands at his sudden boldness and burst of energy-but unfortunately it is too late…..Mr Manmohan Singh has squandered the good will and the trust people had reposed in the Congress and hence it is the Congress’swan song that he has just began to sing.
Dr Mrs Hilda Raja,
Vadodara,Gujarat

Advertisements

Entry filed under: Uncategorized.

The Washington Post and its postmortem of the UPA2 Shamefully Privileged

6 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Chithra  |  September 24, 2012 at 4:42 pm

    Some one said this on Twitter,
    Joy ‏@Joydas
    Manmohan Singh is right that Money doesnt grow in Trees. It Grows in Branches – of Swiss Banks
    Regards,

    Reply
  • 2. hilda raja  |  September 25, 2012 at 2:51 am

    How very correct you are Chitra-I missed that-Money grows in the branches of all the banks in tax havens-And the point is MMSingh is very aware of this and yet tries to mislead the nation..All the best to you.
    HR

    Reply
  • 3. Poor Indian  |  September 30, 2012 at 7:11 am

    “Money does not grow on trees” Yes, I agree ,
    “Sonia Gandhi 4th richest politician in the world” http://www.weeklyblitz.net/2584/sonia-gandhi-4th-richest-politician-in-the-world

    Reply
  • 4. Pratap Bahadur  |  October 2, 2012 at 1:03 pm

    MMSINGH IS CAMBRIDGE & OXFORD EDUCATED, NOT HARVARD.
    JUST A CORRECTION OTHERWISE AN EXCELLENT ARTICLE

    Reply
    • 5. hilda raja  |  October 7, 2012 at 7:58 am

      Thank you Pratap-someone else also pointed out this error.Well MMSingh is a coporate man-he is in politics by default.All same person-only the coats are different Harvard-Cambridge and Oxford.

      Reply
  • 6. vikram  |  October 24, 2012 at 11:29 am

    Thanks for a wonderfull article, request you to fax the same to MMS office.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Categories

Blog Stats

  • 69,620 hits

Feeds


%d bloggers like this: